When not knowing is the hardest part
Waiting for results. A future you cannot picture. A decision that will not come. For many people the worst of it is not what might happen, but not knowing. This page explains why uncertainty is so hard to bear, where the difficulty comes from, how I work with it, and where you can start.
What uncertainty does to us
Uncertainty is not knowing what will happen. The trouble is seldom the not knowing itself. It is what mind and body do with it: for many of us, "I don't know" is felt as "I am in danger".
Nobody enjoys uncertainty. In 2016 researchers at University College London asked volunteers to play a game in which they might be given a mild electric shock. The people who showed the most stress were not those who knew a shock was coming. They were the ones who could not tell either way.
That was one laboratory study, and I would not lean on it too hard. But it fits what people tell me, which is that the waiting is often worse than the news. People also differ a great deal in how much not knowing they can carry. Some manage a fair amount. Others, for reasons that usually make sense once you know their history, find even a little of it very hard.
Uncertainty and anxiety overlap so much that it can be hard to tell them apart. Anxiety is very often what uncertainty feels like from the inside. My page on anxiety covers worry, panic and the rest. This page looks at the not knowing itself.
In the body
- Not being able to settle or sit still
- A knot in the stomach, a tight chest
- Lying awake going over the possibilities
- A jolt when the phone rings or the post arrives
- Or the opposite: heavy, numb, switched off
In the mind
- "What if?" going round and round
- Running through every outcome, mostly the worst ones
- Not being able to think about anything else
- Needing to know, now
- A feeling that you cannot plan, hope or rest until it is settled
In daily life
- Checking: the phone, the symptoms, the bank account
- Searching the internet late at night
- Asking for reassurance, which works for about an hour
- Lists, plans and back-up plans
- Putting decisions off, or making them in a rush to end the suspense
- Avoiding anything new or open-ended
Why not knowing is hard for everyone
Two ideas have helped me understand this. Neither is settled science. Both are serious attempts to explain something we all recognise, and what follows is my own summary.
The fear beneath other fears
The psychologist Nicholas Carleton has argued that fear of the unknown may be the most basic human fear, the one that lies beneath the rest. Fear of illness, of failure, of being left: look closely at any of them and there is something we cannot know or control.
If he is right, it would explain why uncertainty troubles people who are not otherwise anxious, and why being reassured about one worry so often just makes room for the next.
A brain built to predict
Jeremy Holmes, a British psychiatrist and psychotherapist, draws on neuroscience to describe the brain as an organ of prediction. It is forever guessing what will happen next, and it registers surprise as a kind of alarm. We quieten the alarm in two ways: by doing something about the situation, or by revising our picture of it. Under strain we manage neither very well alone.
His point is that we borrow steadiness from one another. A child borrows it from a parent. An adult can borrow it from a friend, a partner or a counsellor, until they can think clearly again. His book, written mainly for therapists, is The Brain Has a Mind of Its Own.
Why it is harder for some of us
When someone tells me they cannot stand not knowing, I am listening for three things. Often more than one is there.
A situation that really is uncertain
You are waiting for a scan, a verdict, a decision about your job. Or your partner has died, and the future you had planned has gone with them. There is nothing wrong with your reaction. Anyone would be unsettled. What you need is steadiness while you wait, not to be told you are overreacting.
Not having had somewhere steady to stand
Children explore when they have someone reliable to come back to. John Bowlby called this a secure base. With one, the unknown is interesting. Without one, it is a threat. If the adults around you were unpredictable, frightening or simply absent, you may have learned very early that not knowing what comes next means danger. The body can go on reacting that way long after the mind has forgotten where it learned to.
Studies do find that people who are less secure in their close relationships tend to find uncertainty harder to bear. They cannot show that the one causes the other, but it fits what I see. The same thing can happen in adult life, when the person or the community that steadied you is lost.
A habit of needing to be sure
Some of us learned that we could only relax once everything was known, checked and settled. Worry then becomes a way of trying to manufacture certainty: if I think it through once more, I will be safe. It works for a few minutes, which is exactly why it becomes a habit.
The psychologist Michel Dugas and his colleagues, who have studied this for many years, liken it to an allergy. A small amount of uncertainty sets off a very large reaction.
It matters which of these is at work, because the help needed is different. Someone waiting for a scan mostly needs steadiness and some practical footing. Someone who has never been able to bear not knowing needs those too, and then something that goes further back.
The forms it takes
These are the forms I meet most often. You may recognise yourself in more than one.
Waiting for results
A scan, a biopsy, a date for an operation. Days or weeks of living in two futures at once. People often say the waiting was worse than the news, whichever way it went.
An illness that may come back
Treatment has finished and everyone expects you to be relieved. Instead, every ache raises the question. Or you live with a condition whose course nobody can predict.
A future without the person you planned it with
After a death or a separation, the future you had pictured has gone and no other has taken its place. "What happens to me now?"
Work and money
Rumours of redundancy, a contract ending, a business in trouble, a career that has stopped. Not knowing whether you can pay the mortgage sits underneath everything else.
Where do I stand?
Uncertainty inside a relationship: whether they will stay, whether you will, whether you can trust what you are told.
Decisions you cannot make
Stay or go, speak or keep quiet, this job or that one. You go round and round because no option comes with a guarantee, and in time not deciding becomes a place to live.
A lifetime of "what if?"
There is no single crisis. You have always needed to know, always planned for the worst, always found surprises difficult, even pleasant ones. It is tiring for you, and wearing for the people around you.
Not knowing who you are now
A role has ended, and the uncertainty is about yourself. I have written about this on my page on life transitions.
The large questions
Mortality, meaning, what any of it is for. They tend to arrive after a death, a diagnosis, or a birthday with a nought in it. For some people they are bound up with faith and doubt, and both are welcome in the room.
The state of the world
The news, the climate, war, prices. You cannot influence it and cannot stop reading about it, and it leaves a low hum of dread under the day.
What we are aiming for
In a letter of 1817 the poet John Keats praised what he called negative capability: being "capable of being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason".
The journalist Maggie Jackson has gathered recent research which suggests he was on to something. Being unsure is uncomfortable, but it also keeps a mind open, curious and able to learn. Her book is Uncertain.
None of this makes a hospital waiting room pleasant. But it tells us what to aim for. Nobody can get rid of uncertainty. What a person can do is grow their capacity to stand in it.
I do not diagnose; that is for a GP or psychiatrist. You do not need a diagnosis to come and see me.
How I work with uncertainty
I cannot make an uncertain thing certain, and I won't pretend to. What can change is how much not knowing you are able to carry, and what you have to stand on while you carry it.
Before any method there is the relationship. Much of what helps is being with someone steady while you do not know. That is the borrowed steadiness I described above, and I don't regard it as a preliminary to the real work. It is a large part of the work.
Beyond that there are four strands. The first two are about managing what is in front of you, and if you are waiting on something with a date attached they may be all you need. The third and fourth go deeper, for when the difficulty with not knowing is an old one.
-
Settling the body first
When not knowing has tipped you into alarm, your body is getting ready to fight or to run, or it has shut down. Nobody thinks clearly in that state, so that is where we begin. I will help you find what steadies you: your breathing, your feet on the floor, a place, a person or a memory that brings some ease. Sometimes I add slow tapping, left and right, while you hold a steadying memory in mind. Some people find it helps the memory settle in. Others prefer to do without, and that is fine.
This is not a way of avoiding the subject. It is what makes it possible to look at it.
-
Managing what is in front of you
There is an old and useful distinction, which many people know from the Serenity Prayer and which Stephen Covey made popular as circles of concern and influence. We sort the situation into three.
What I can control
What I do today, what I ask, who I tell, how I look after myself.
What I can influence
Other people's choices, how well prepared I am, how a conversation goes.
What is out of my hands
The result, the decision, the past, what other people finally do.
It shows where your effort is worth spending and where it is being poured away, and most people find that a relief.
We also practise a different relationship with the anxious thoughts. Instead of having the problem pressed up against your face, you learn to hold it further off and watch it: there is "what if" again. Some people like to picture each thought as a leaf dropped on a stream, noticed and left to float by. The thoughts still come. They take up less room.
I will be honest about the limits of all this. It manages the feeling. It does not reach the story underneath, which is what keeps sending the body into alarm.
-
The story underneath
If not knowing has always been hard for you, then somewhere, usually long ago and for good reason, you learned that it is dangerous. We look for where. What was it like as a child not to know what mood someone would come home in, or whether they would come home at all? What did you have to do in order to feel safe?
A part of you may still be standing guard, convinced that if it stops scanning for trouble, trouble will come. We get to know that part and what it fears, without arguing with it.
Sometimes it helps to hold two things together and feel them both at once, in the body. One is the old conviction that you cannot be safe unless you are sure. The other is what you also know to be true now: that some things are certain, that there are people and facts which hold, even while this one question stays open. When the two are really felt side by side, the old conviction can loosen. In my experience argument alone does not shift it. It seems to need to be felt.
-
Something firmer than certainty
If certainty is not on offer, what can you stand on? Partly, on knowing who you are. We look at the evidence of your own life: the hard things you have already come through, and how you did it. "I've been here before" is worth a great deal. I am careful with it, though. "I always cope" is not always true, and some things have no precedent to point to: a first serious diagnosis, a first year alone. Then the honest position is not "it will be all right". It is nearer to "whatever comes, I will meet it as myself, and with people beside me".
We also come back to what matters to you, because that does not have to wait for the result. While the large question stays open, you can still be the parent, friend or neighbour you want to be today.
For some people faith gives assurance, a framework to live from and a place to belong, and it is welcome in the room. For everyone, belonging somewhere makes uncertainty easier to bear. If you have lost your people, finding some again is part of the work.
There is no fixed number of sessions. A wait with a date on it may need only a few. Where the need to be sure goes back a long way, the work takes longer. We review it together as we go.
Integrative counselling. My work with uncertainty draws on John Bowlby and Jeremy Holmes, on Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (Steven Hayes, Russ Harris), on Internal Family Systems (Richard Schwartz), on coherence therapy (Bruce Ecker and Laurel Hulley), and on attachment-informed approaches. The research summarised on this page is by Nicholas Carleton, Michel Dugas and colleagues, and Archy de Berker's team at University College London. The wording on this page is my own.
Where to start
I am not going to suggest techniques for stopping worry here. What helps depends on you and your circumstances, and that belongs in a conversation, not on a web page. These are ways of informing yourself and of finding the right help, and each one leaves the decisions with you.
Ask how you will hear
You are entitled to ask the hospital or surgery when your results are expected, how they will reach you, and whom to ring if they do not. Knowing the process takes away one layer of not knowing.
If cancer is in question, the Macmillan Support Line is free on 0808 808 00 00, from 8am to 8pm every day, for patients and for family and friends.
See your GP
If worry has become constant, or is costing you sleep, it is worth a conversation with your doctor. The NHS has a short self-assessment for anxiety and low mood, built on the questionnaires that GPs use.
You can also refer yourself to NHS Talking Therapies. Seeing me does not replace any of this, and the two can go on side by side.
Read about it
Russ Harris's The Happiness Trap explains, for the general reader, the idea of standing back from anxious thoughts and steering by what matters to you.
Maggie Jackson's Uncertain is a thoughtful account of what not knowing is good for.
Free guides to keep
Coming Back to Safe
How the body moves between calm, alarm and shutdown, and how it finds its way back.
Read the guide →The Part That Never Rests
If some part of you is always on guard, scanning for what might go wrong.
Open the guide →Two Minds About It
If you cannot decide, and not deciding has become its own kind of stuck.
Open the guide →Life transitions
When the uncertainty follows a change: retirement, separation, a death, a role that has ended.
Read the page →What people often ask
Isn't this just anxiety?
Very often, yes. Much anxiety is the body's response to not knowing. I find it useful to look at the uncertainty directly, though, because it leads to a different question. Not only "how do I calm down?" but "why is not knowing so hard for me, and what would let me bear more of it?"
Can you tell me it will be all right?
No, and I think you would stop trusting me if I did. Nobody knows how your situation will turn out. What I can do is stay steady alongside you while you do not know, which most people find helps more than reassurance does.
My results are due in a fortnight. Is it worth coming for so short a time?
It can be. Some people come for two or three sessions simply to get through a wait, and that is a perfectly good use of counselling. Others find the wait has stirred up something older, and choose to carry on afterwards.
I have always been like this. Can it change?
I cannot promise a result. What I can say is that a need for certainty which was learned can be understood, and that people do find they are able to carry more than they used to. When it goes back to childhood it takes time, and we do not rush it.
Isn't it sensible to prepare for the worst?
Planning is sensible. The test is whether it ends. Planning leads to a decision or an action, and then stops. Worry goes round the same ground again and leaves you no better prepared. Part of the work is learning to tell the two apart.
Someone I love keeps asking me for reassurance. What should I do?
It is wearing, and you are not failing them if the reassurance does not last. It rarely does, because it answers the question and not the fear beneath it. Staying calm and close tends to help more than finding the perfect answer. You are welcome to get in touch on your own account.
Does faith have a place in this?
If it matters to you, yes. For many people faith is where they find assurance, and somewhere to belong, when little else is certain. For others a crisis shakes their faith, and that needs room too. I am comfortable with either, and I will not raise it unless you do.
If you need help right now
Counselling is not an emergency service. If you feel unable to keep yourself safe, call 999 or go to A&E. For urgent mental health help, call NHS 111 and choose the mental health option. To talk to someone at any hour, the Samaritans are free on 116 123.
Rather talk it through?
A page can only take you so far. If any of this sounds like you, get in touch and we can have a free 15-minute introductory chat. There is no obligation to book anything afterwards, and you won't be asked to say more than you want to.