The old life has ended. The new one has not begun.
Retirement, divorce, a death, children leaving, a job gone, a body that no longer does what it did. The change itself may take a day. Catching up with it takes a good deal longer. This page explains what a transition is, why it can be so unsettling, how I work with it, and where you can start.
What a life transition is
A change is something that happens to you. A transition is what happens in you: letting go of who you were, living for a while without a clear answer, and slowly finding out who you are now.
The distinction comes from William Bridges, who spent his working life studying how people come through change. The change, he said, is the event: the last day at work, the decree, the funeral, the removal van. It has a date. The transition has no date. It begins with an ending, and it keeps its own time.
That is why so many people are caught out. The practical side is finished, everyone else has moved on, and you are left unsettled, flat or lost without being able to say why. Nothing has gone wrong. You are in the middle of something that takes time, and that the world around you makes very little room for.
In the body
- Tiredness out of proportion to what you are doing
- Broken sleep, or waking early with your mind already busy
- Restlessness, and not being able to settle to anything
- A tight chest or a churning stomach with no clear cause
- Tears that arrive without warning
In the mind
- "Who am I now?"
- Feeling adrift between two lives
- Looking back all the time, or not being able to look back at all
- Doubting a decision you were sure of
- A future you cannot picture
- A sense that you ought to be coping better than this
In daily life
- Days without shape
- Avoiding people who will ask "so what are you doing now?"
- Filling every hour, or doing very little
- Not knowing how to introduce yourself
- Sudden big decisions, or no decisions at all
The three parts of a transition
Bridges described a transition as having three parts. It is a picture, drawn from his years of helping people through change, and not a law that research has proved. I use it because people recognise themselves in it. Anthropologists had seen the same shape long before, in the rites of passage that traditional societies use to see a person from one stage of life into the next.
An ending
Something has to be let go: a role, a routine, a picture of the future, a version of yourself. There is loss in this even when the change is welcome, and the loss needs its due.
The in-between
The old has gone and the new has not arrived. Bridges called it the neutral zone. The anthropologist Victor Turner called it being "betwixt and between". It feels like being lost. It is also where most of the real change takes place.
A beginning
Not the start date of the new job or the day you move in, but the point at which the new life begins to feel like yours. It can't be forced, and it tends to come later than you would like.
Please don't read these as stages to be passed in order. The writer Bruce Feiler interviewed more than two hundred people about the upheavals in their lives. In his interviews people took the three parts in any order, went back and forth between them, and found the whole thing lasted longer than they had expected.
Research on bereavement points the same way. Margaret Stroebe and Henk Schut describe healthy grieving as a to-and-fro: some days facing the loss, other days getting on with rebuilding ordinary life. The moving between the two is how it works. So a good week followed by a bad one doesn't mean you have gone backwards.
The ending: what has actually gone
People are often puzzled, and a little ashamed, to find themselves struggling with something they chose. The retirement was planned for years. The baby was longed for. The marriage needed to end.
Nancy Schlossberg, a counselling psychologist who studied adult transitions for decades, offers a useful way to look at it. What matters is not whether a change is good or bad. It is how much of your ordinary life it alters. She names four things.
Your roles
What you are to other people: colleague, wife, captain, the one who looks after Mum.
Your relationships
Who you see in an ordinary week, and who has quietly dropped away.
Your routines
What gets you up, where you go, the shape of a Tuesday.
Your assumptions
What you took for granted about yourself, about other people, and about how life goes.
A change that touches all four will shake you, however welcome it is.
She also noticed that some of the hardest transitions are caused by something that did not happen: the baby that never came, the promotion, the reconciliation, the recovery. Nobody sends a card for these, and people tend to keep them to themselves.
Losses that have no funeral
The family therapist Pauline Boss gave the name "ambiguous loss" to losses that are real but unclear. A husband who is still here but altered by dementia. A child who has grown up and gone, alive and well and no longer at the table. A former partner you still meet at the handover. A body that works, but not as it did.
There is no ritual for losses like these and no day on which they are over, which is what makes them so hard to grieve. Her advice is to stop waiting for closure and to practise holding two things at once: he is here, and he is gone. I am the same person, and I am not.
She writes about it at ambiguousloss.com.
The in-between: "who am I now?"
This is the question I hear more than any other. From the mother whose youngest has just started school. From the man a year into retirement. From the woman whose husband has left, or has died. Each of them had an answer to "who are you?" that they never needed to think about, and it has gone.
For a while there is no new answer. That is what the in-between is, and it is not a failing on your part. It helps to know that a role is something you had. It was never the whole of you, though it can take time, and sometimes help, before that feels true.
"Who am I?" is partly "who are we?"
A good deal of our sense of who we are comes from the groups we belong to: a workplace, a team, a regiment, the school gate, a congregation, a marriage. When a change takes one of these away, a piece of identity goes with it.
The psychologist Catherine Haslam and her colleagues have followed people through retirement, including retirement from competitive sport. Those who kept hold of some of the groups that mattered to them, and joined at least one new one, tended to adjust better. Belonging is not an extra. It is part of how a person stays themselves through change.
Some people become lost and then stuck in being lost, with one part of them pulling forward and another holding on. If that sounds familiar, my guide Two Minds About It may be worth a look.
The beginning: finding out by doing
Herminia Ibarra, of London Business School, studied people who changed career. Almost none of them worked out who they wanted to be next by thinking about it. The ones who got there tried things: a course, a conversation, a small project, a day's volunteering. The doing came first and the knowing followed.
Her study was of people changing career, but I think it holds for other changes too, and it takes some pressure off. You don't need the answer before you take a step. Her book is Working Identity.
The forms it takes
I work with adults, and these are the transitions I meet most often. Yours may not be on the list.
Leaving home, leaving university
The structure that held you has gone, friends have scattered, and everyone else seems to know what they are doing. First jobs belong here too, along with the quiet question "is this it?"
Becoming a parent
Longed for or not, it rearranges everything: body, sleep, work, your relationship, your sense of who you are. There is even a word for becoming a mother, matrescence, coined by the anthropologist Dana Raphael to sit alongside adolescence. Fathers go through a version of their own.
When the children need you less
The youngest starts school, or the last one leaves home. Years of being needed all day give way to hours of quiet, and the question arrives: who am I now? It can be sharpest if you set a career aside.
Separation and divorce
Whether you left or were left, you lose a shared future as well as a partner, and often a home, friends, in-laws and daily contact with your children. Who are you without "we"?
After a death
Losing a partner changes every hour of the day and every plan you had made. Alongside the grief there is the lonely, practical business of becoming someone who does all of it alone.
Redundancy, or the end of a career
A job is income, but it is also structure, standing, company, and a ready answer to "what do you do?" Losing one can feel like losing yourself. It is harder still where the work was a whole way of life: elite sport, the forces, farming, ministry.
Changing direction
Leaving a secure career for something that matters more to you, or going back to work or study after years away. Chosen, exciting, and still frightening, because for a while you are a beginner again.
Retirement
It is meant to be a reward, and for many people it is. It also removes role, routine and colleagues in a single day, and puts two people into a house that each of them is used to having to themselves.
A changed body
Illness, injury, a diagnosis, the menopause, or simply finding that your body will no longer do what it did. You are working out who you are within new limits, often without knowing what lies ahead.
Becoming a carer, or ceasing to be one
Caring can take over a life by degrees, until little is left that is yours. When it ends, through a recovery, a move into a home or a death, relief, guilt and emptiness can all arrive together.
Moving, and losing your people
A new town or a new country. Leaving a church, a club or a community that held you. The loss of belonging is easy to underestimate until it has happened.
The middle of life
Nothing in particular has happened, and yet the life you have built no longer quite fits. Ambitions have been reached or quietly let go, parents are ageing, time feels shorter. It is less a crisis than a question.
Transitions seldom come one at a time. Retirement arrives in the same year as a parent's death and a daughter's divorce. If several have landed together, it is no wonder you are tired.
Sometimes a transition turns into something heavier. If your mood has been low for weeks, my page on depression may help. If the hardest part is simply not knowing what comes next, I have written a separate page on uncertainty, because I think it is a subject of its own.
How I work with transitions
Before any method there is the relationship. A transition is easier to go through with someone steady alongside you, who is not alarmed by it and has no stake in which way you go.
I don't think of a transition as a problem to be solved. It is something to be gone through, and my part is to help you go through it with your eyes open, at your own pace, without being hurried out of the uncomfortable middle. I came to counselling after a long career in business, so I have some feeling for this from the inside.
What I do depends on you and on what you bring. The four strands below follow the shape described above: the ending, the in-between, and the beginning.
-
Giving the ending its due
Most people try to skip this part. They are told, or they tell themselves, to look forward and be positive. But something has ended, and it needs acknowledging before anything new can take root. So we look at what you have actually lost. Not only the obvious thing, but the role, the routine, the company, the future you had pictured.
There may be grief. There may be anger, or relief, and sometimes all three in one session. All of it is welcome. This holds for changes you chose as well. You can be glad you left and still miss what you left.
-
Staying with the in-between
This is the hardest part, and the one people most want to be rescued from. I won't hurry you towards an answer, because answers seized in order to end the discomfort seldom last. We work instead on making the in-between bearable: steadying the body when it is on alert, and finding enough rest and routine to stand on.
Often a person is in two minds. One part wants to get on with life. Another is holding hard to what was, or is afraid of what comes next. I work a good deal with these different parts of a person. Neither is wrong, and neither needs to be overruled. When each has been properly heard, the deadlock has a chance to ease.
-
Finding what is still you
Here we come back to "who am I now?" We look for what has come with you through every change so far: what you value, what you believe in, what you would not want to live without. In my experience it is rarely the Aga or the job. It is what lies underneath: the things you treasure about the people you love, and the kind of person you want to be for them. Once that is clear, it gives a direction when nothing else does.
We may also look back at other upheavals you have come through, and how you did it. This is not to tell you that this one will be fine, which nobody can promise. It is because people forget what they are made of. For some people faith is part of what holds steady, and it is welcome in the room.
-
Trying things out
A new life is built more than it is discovered. As energy returns, we look at small experiments: a conversation, a class, a day's volunteering, a group you might belong to. I may ask what you would notice if things were a little better, and where that is already happening.
Belonging matters a great deal here. People seldom find their feet alone. They find them among others, and working out where your people are now is part of what we do.
Some transitions bring larger questions with them: getting older, the limits of the body, the fact that time is not endless. I don't steer round these. They can be faced, with courage and with support, and looking at them squarely often makes it clearer what a person wants to do with the time and strength they have.
There is no fixed number of sessions. The work takes the time it needs, and we review it together as we go. Nobody announces that a transition is complete. Most people simply notice one day that they have stopped thinking about it.
Integrative counselling. The ideas about transition summarised on this page come from William Bridges, Nancy Schlossberg, Bruce Feiler, Margaret Stroebe and Henk Schut, Pauline Boss, Catherine Haslam and Herminia Ibarra. My own way of working draws on John Bowlby and Jeremy Holmes, on Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (Steven Hayes, Russ Harris), on Internal Family Systems (Richard Schwartz), and on solution-focused and attachment-informed approaches. The wording on this page is my own.
Where to start
I am not going to suggest techniques here. What helps depends on you and your circumstances, and that belongs in a conversation, not on a web page. These are ways of informing yourself and of finding the right help, and each one leaves the decisions with you.
Read about it
William Bridges's Transitions is short, plain, and has been in print since 1980.
Bruce Feiler's Life Is in the Transitions is built from hundreds of people's own accounts. Either may show you that what you are going through has a shape.
Sort the practical side
A transition is harder when money, housing or work are up in the air. Citizens Advice gives free, confidential advice on redundancy, benefits, separation and debt.
Age UK has a helpful page on preparing emotionally for retirement, and an advice line on 0800 678 1602.
After a death, the Cruse helpline is free on 0808 808 1677.
See who is out there
Herefordshire's Talk Community Directory lists hundreds of local groups and activities, from walking and crafts to carers' groups. You need not want to join anything yet. It can help just to see what is there.
If your sleep or mood has been badly affected for more than a couple of weeks, it is worth a conversation with your GP as well.
Free guides to keep
Two Minds About It
If part of you wants to move on and part of you cannot. Why being torn makes sense, and what helps.
Open the guide →The Shape of Grief
For the ending inside every transition. How grief moves, and why it does not keep to anyone's timetable.
Open the guide →Worth Beyond Usefulness
If your sense of worth was bound up with a job or a role that has now gone.
Open the guide →When not knowing is the hardest part
Why uncertainty is so hard to bear, where the difficulty comes from, and how I work with it.
Read the page →What people often ask
I chose this change. Why do I feel so low?
Because choosing something does not spare you the ending that comes with it. You have still lost roles, routines and people, and perhaps a picture of yourself. Feeling the loss does not mean the decision was wrong.
How long does a transition take?
I cannot honestly say, and I would be wary of anyone who could. It is usually longer than people expect and longer than those around them allow for. We review regularly, and you decide when you have had what you came for.
Is this a transition, grief or depression?
They overlap. Every transition has some grief in it. Depression is different: the low mood becomes constant and turns on you, so that you feel worthless as well as lost. We can work out together which you are dealing with. Often it is more than one.
Is this a midlife crisis?
I do not find the phrase much use. It makes a serious question sound like a joke about sports cars. If the life you have built no longer fits, that deserves proper attention, at whatever age it happens.
Everyone says I should be enjoying this. What is wrong with me?
Nothing. New parents and the newly retired hear it most. Other people see what you have gained. You are also living with what you have lost, and both are real. You are allowed to say so here.
I have no idea what I want. Is there any point in coming until I do?
Yes. Not knowing is where most people start, and it is a perfectly good place to begin. You do not need a goal or a plan. Finding out what you want is part of the work.
Can I come before the change has happened?
You can, and it often helps. People come ahead of a retirement, a move, a separation or an operation, to think it through while there is still time to prepare.
If you need help right now
Counselling is not an emergency service. If you feel unable to keep yourself safe, call 999 or go to A&E. For urgent mental health help, call NHS 111 and choose the mental health option. To talk to someone at any hour, the Samaritans are free on 116 123.
Rather talk it through?
A page can only take you so far. If any of this sounds like you, get in touch and we can have a free 15-minute introductory chat. There is no obligation to book anything afterwards, and you won't be asked to say more than you want to.