The thinking behind it

Four experts, four different questions, and an honest account of where they disagree.

The profile draws on four people whose work I return to often. Each answers a different question, which is what makes them worth combining. Barkley explains what goes wrong day to day. Steer explains who gets missed, and why. Maté offers one account of how it came to be this way in this person. Kustow asks what to do about it.

This profile is my own synthesis, inspired by their work. It is not endorsed by or affiliated with any of them.

The self-regulation lens

Russell A. Barkley

Barkley's central claim is that ADHD is a difficulty of executive function and self-regulation, not of attention or knowledge. People know what to do; they cannot reliably do what they know at the moment it matters. He groups everyday executive difficulties into managing time, organising and problem-solving, self-restraint, self-motivation, and regulating emotion.

Three of his ideas shape the profile. Time blindness: the future does not feel real until it is now. Interest-led motivation: effort that depends on interest, urgency, novelty or challenge more than on importance. And the practical consequence, that help works best when it is placed where the difficulty happens (a visible clock, a broken-down task, another person alongside) and not delivered as more information.

The missed-and-masked lens

Dr Joanne Steer

The book Steer edited argues that ADHD is no less impairing in women and girls but is routinely missed, because the familiar picture was built on hyperactive boys. Women often come to services with anxiety or low mood, with ADHD underneath. Many compensate well, usually at real cost to their health.

From this come the profile's questions about masking (performing competence so the difficulty doesn't show) and scaffolding (private systems that hold life together until a baby, a promotion or perimenopause overloads them). Her warning, in my words: we see the effort and miss the struggle.

The developmental and relational lens

Dr Gabor Maté

In Scattered Minds, Maté argues that what is inherited is sensitivity, and that ADHD takes shape when a highly sensitive child's nervous system develops under stress. Shame is central to his account, not incidental, and many adults carry a sense of worth that depends on performing. Recovery, for him, includes learning to look after yourself as an act of care.

This is where the profile's questions about sensitivity and about shame and worth come from. It is also what makes the profile a counsellor's tool and not a symptom checklist.

The whole-person lens

Dr James Kustow

Kustow, a consultant psychiatrist who was himself diagnosed in adulthood, holds that the aim is to thrive with ADHD and not merely to manage it. He treats ADHD as a matter of regulation across the whole body, looks for it beneath anxiety, low mood and relationship difficulties, and gives particular weight to sensitivity to rejection.

Two of his ideas run through the profile: that each person's ADHD has its own individual shape, and that small, steadying habits come before big productivity systems.

Where they agree

  • ADHD is a difficulty of regulation (of attention, time, effort, emotion and the body) more than a simple shortage of attention.
  • Emotional intensity matters, even though it is not among the diagnostic criteria.
  • Shame, and the accumulated sense of failure, cause much of the suffering.
  • Understanding your own pattern, and building the right supports around it, changes how life goes.

Where they disagree

On one point they clash, and it is better to say so than to blend them into one voice. Barkley holds that ADHD is predominantly genetic and neurodevelopmental, and he is critical of accounts that locate its cause in early environment. Maté holds that genes confer sensitivity, and that the difficulty develops through how that sensitivity meets the early world. These positions are not fully reconcilable.

How I hold it

Researchers disagree about where ADHD comes from. Most agree genes play a large part. Some, like Gabor Maté, also emphasise how a sensitive temperament meets early life. In therapy, we're less interested in blame than in understanding what your nervous system learned, and what it needs now.

They also differ in emphasis on medication. Barkley and Kustow regard it as a legitimate and often very effective part of treatment. Maté accepts it can help but warns against relying on it alone. None of them argues that understanding yourself replaces assessment; they argue it should not be the only thing that happens.

Seven ideas the profile is built on

These are my own synthesis.

  1. A fingerprint, not just a label. A diagnosis tells you which category you fall into; your own pattern tells you the shape of your days. Two people with the same diagnosis can live completely different lives.
  2. Regulation, not willpower. You don't lack knowledge or character. You lack reliable access to what you already know.
  3. The cost of coping. It's not how well you cope. It's what coping costs.
  4. Sensitivity is the soil. Sensitivity isn't a flaw to fix. It's a trait to look after.
  5. Shame is the second injury. Years of being called lazy, too much or not trying leave a mark. That mark can heal.
  6. Help where it happens. Don't try harder. Build differently.
  7. Understanding first, decisions second. Whatever route you take, it starts with knowing yourself.

Sources

  • Barkley, R. A. Barkley Deficits in Executive Functioning Scale (BDEFS for Adults). New York: Guilford Press.
  • Kustow, J. (2024). How to Thrive with Adult ADHD. London: Vermilion.
  • Maté, G. (1999). Scattered Minds.
  • Steer, J. (Ed.) (2021). Understanding ADHD in Girls and Women. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

The profile's statements, its ten areas, its seven patterns and its starting points are all written by me. No wording is taken from any published questionnaire or book. This profile is my own synthesis, inspired by their work. It is not endorsed by or affiliated with any of them.

Map my profile →

Rather talk it through?

If this raised more than it answered, I offer a relaxed 15-minute introductory chat, with no obligation, to get to know each other and see whether working together might help.

Or call 07712 155802  •  martyn@martynkylecounselling.co.uk